Home
| About | News | Books | Works | Appearances | Contact
Why is literature
not necessarily elitist? At the Hudson
Valley Writers' Center in New York, we recently had a debate about whether we
might become an elitist literary organization if we removed certain programs
that were not directly literary. At the
root of our debate were assumptions about what is 'literature.'
I wondered why
someone would even equate or relate the 'literary' with 'elitism,' unless they
had a strange view of what literature is, or should be. For example, I write about la gente decente from El Paso
--janitors, maids, farmworkers--- in part because I
grew up poor, and I feel I understand this community. So I found it strange that people would say
'literature' is necessarily 'elitist.'
I think you can
write good stories, excellent in every literary sense, that are also about
social change, difficult questions of class, the morality and minds of the
poor, which too often are overlooked in stereotypes of the disenfranchised. I certainly don't write 'elitist literature'
in any sense. I always assumed writing
was, indeed, outreach to the poor, to those voices I grew up with who were not
heard. I definitely never felt guilty
about my writing.
So I think someone
who thinks that writers and their 'literature' are 'elitist' must have a
certain view of 'good literature' or literature with a capital L that must be
challenged. Literature is not just about
pretty images or beautiful words. It is
not an activity that is somehow divorced from raw moral conflicts or the life
of the poor or life-and-death questions, which we all face. When you divorce writing from these concerns,
then, of course, 'literature' becomes a meaningless, self-referential Art that
is elitist. But that is a peculiar view
of literature, which I would not call 'Literature.' James Joyce, for example, is famous for
writing about a day in the life of the Irish poor, in Ulysses. Faulkner wrote about the moral conflicts
between blacks and whites in the South. Dagoberto Gilb writes about
working-class Chicanos without a shred of sentimentality.
So I found it very
natural to think that our outreach at the Writers' Center should be
accomplished through writing, with
our readings series, classes and workshops, and publications, and not outreach
as something separate from the main activities of writing itself. Only if you see 'literature' as divorced from
the common man, and his concerns, will you become worried that a focus on
writing itself will become 'elitist.' I
would argue that you have a peculiar definition of literature if you think that
way.
A corollary of this
peculiar view of literature, as an ornament, and not a social force in itself,
is that you will assume that the poor will not be able to produce, or even
appreciate, proper 'Literature.' If
Literature is only about the proper use of English, its prettiness, unique and
astonishing sentence constructions, then someone writing about, say, characters
from Ysleta or Spanish Harlem is not writing Literature at all. Let's just call it (patronizingly) Ethnic
Literature (which separates it from 'real Literature'). This peculiar, ornamental view of Literature
will assume the disenfranchised are not interested in 'real Literature' or
'excellent writing.' Again, these
assumptions should be challenged.
Poor people discuss
ideas. Poor people read. Poor people want to learn. They want to write well and have their voices
heard. Everybody enjoys good writing.
We also need to get rid of the stereotypes that la gente
decente do not think and do not debate moral
issues. They do. The problem is that too often they are
ignored or thought of as unimportant.
Sometimes Chicanos themselves think this way about their community. It is difficult enough when the rich suburbs
of New York City have a stereotypical image of who you are, which you need to
change. But let's not do it to
ourselves, too. I hope these
philosophical musings inspire a good debate.
There is no guilt in the heart when you know what you do is true.
This newspaper
article appeared in the Sunday Books section of the El Paso Times on December 22, 2002.